News  /  November 18, 2026  /  

Ray Seilie Discusses Copyright Infringement and Fair Use in the Age of AI for Vulture’s Coverage of the Ongoing Elvis Presley Catalogue Litigation

Ray Seilie was recently featured in Vulture providing insights into the copyright case filed against Anthropic by the rights holders to hundreds of Elvis Presley songs, and how AI is bringing up new considerations over fair use.

Ray notes that other than the lawsuit involving one of the most famous rock musicians in history, it is also distinct from other AI lawsuits in that rather than focusing solely on Anthropic’s use of copyrighted songs as training data, the lawsuit also examines whether Claude generates outputs that closely reproduce those works.

He explains, “there is a lot of ambiguity over whether merely training an AI model on copyrighted works constitutes copyright infringement.” By focusing on Claude’s outputs, the plaintiffs are raising a separate question about whether the AI-generated material itself infringes copyrighted works.

Addressing the fair-use arguments AI companies have relied on to defend their training practices, Ray compares AI learning to how students study music and incorporate what they hear into their own creative work. AI companies argue that “what AI is doing is no different, except the process of learning and integration is much faster.” However, Ray emphasizes that this argument assumes the copyrighted material was obtained legally, a key issue in the Elvis lawsuit given allegations that Anthropic obtained songs from unauthorized sources.

Turning to the potential outputs of AI models, Ray explains that the distinction between derivative and transformative use could be particularly important in this litigation. The question in the Elvis case is whether Claude’s allegedly similar recreations constitute transformative works or impermissible derivatives of the original songs.

Read the full article in Vulture (subscription may be required).